Colorado workers' compensation has strict rules, and simple mistakes about what not to do while on workers comp can cost you medical care, wage-loss payments, and permanent disability benefits. Ignoring medical treatment, missing deadlines, or giving inconsistent information are common mistakes to avoid that hand ammunition to insurers looking to reduce or deny your claim.
Insurance companies and every insurance adjuster assigned to your file are not on your side-they may use surveillance, social media, and gaps in medical records against you.
Injured workers who follow doctor's orders, report on time, and stay honest with medical providers put themselves in the strongest position to receive full benefits.
Settling too quickly or handling a disputed claim without a lawyer can permanently cost you tens of thousands of dollars in future medical treatment and lost wages.
Steve Johnston has practiced Colorado workers' compensation law since 2002, helping injured workers across Pueblo and the state avoid these mistakes from day one.
If you are currently on workers' comp or were recently hurt at work, call Johnston Law Firm, LLC at (719) 309-9484 or message us online for a free consultation.
Colorado workers' compensation is a no-fault system. You do not need to prove your employer did something wrong to qualify for benefits. But what many people do not realize is that the outcome of your workers comp claim depends heavily on what you do-and what you avoid doing-after the injury happened.
Across Pueblo, Otero, Fremont, Custer, Huerfano, Las Animas, and Crowley Counties, workers lose benefits every year not because their work injury wasn't real, but because they made avoidable mistakes. These errors give the insurance company exactly what it needs to delay, reduce, or deny a claim entirely.
Workers compensation benefits can include medical care for your work related injury, temporary disability benefits to replace lost wages, and permanent impairment compensation if your recovery plateaus. Each one can be jeopardized by the wrong move at the wrong time.
This article walks through thirteen specific mistakes to avoid while on workers' comp in Colorado. If you are currently dealing with a workplace injury or just got hurt at work, call (719) 309-9484 or message Johnston Law Firm online for a free review of your situation before a misstep puts your claim at risk.
Colorado insurers routinely argue that if you don't follow doctor's orders, your injury must not really be serious. That argument gives them a basis to cut off both medical care and wage-loss payments. Ignoring doctor's orders can be used against your claim in hearings and settlement negotiations.
Your authorized treating physician-chosen under Colorado's designated provider rules-controls your treatment plan and your work status. Ignoring that plan is one of the most serious mistakes to avoid.
Behaviors that damage your case:
Missing physical therapy sessions without explanation
Canceling follow-up medical appointments and not rescheduling
Ignoring prescribed medications or recommended diagnostics like MRIs
Skipping referrals to specialists
Every missed appointment is a missed opportunity for healing and creates a gap in your medical records that the insurance adjuster can exploit. Missing medical appointments can lead to loss of benefits outright.
If you need to miss an appointment for a legitimate reason-bad weather in Pueblo, transportation issues, childcare-call in advance, document the reason, and reschedule immediately. Following treatment plans is crucial for successful claims, and delaying medical attention allows insurers to claim the injury is unrelated to work.
If you feel your workers comp doctor is not listening or providing proper medical care, talk to a workers compensation attorney at Johnston Law Firm before simply stopping treatment.
When your doctor releases you to light duty work with physical restrictions, those limitations apply everywhere-at work, at home, and out in the community. Ignoring medical restrictions can lead to immediate denial of benefits.
Engaging in activities outside of prescribed medical restrictions can jeopardize a claim. Insurance companies commonly hire investigators in Colorado to record video of injured workers doing things inconsistent with their restrictions. In the Communal v. City of Westminster case (2022), surveillance was specifically requested because of perceived inconsistencies between reported limitations and observed activity.
Examples that cause problems:
Lifting 50-pound bags of dog food at a Pueblo grocery store while on a 10-pound lift restriction
Roofing your shed in Custer County while restricted from overhead work
Playing full-court basketball while on restrictions for a knee or back injury
Shoveling heavy snow when bending and lifting are restricted
Get a copy of your written work restrictions from your medical provider and keep them handy. Returning to work too soon or exceeding restrictions can worsen an injury and complicate your legal standing. If your employer offers a light duty job that does not match your restrictions, speak with a lawyer at Johnston Law Firm before refusing or accepting the assignment.
Your medical records are essential for validating your claim. Inconsistencies in those records are a favorite weapon for insurance companies fighting workers compensation cases.
From your first urgent care visit in Pueblo to later follow-ups with specialists in Colorado Springs or Denver, describe your injury the same way every time: the date, time, location, how the injury happened, and which body parts were hurt. Providing inconsistent statements creates red flags for insurance companies that are difficult to undo.
What not to do:
Don't forget to mention all painful body parts during each visit
Don't say "I'm fine" when you are not
Don't change your story about how the accident occurred
Don't hide prior injuries-hiding pre-existing conditions can backfire when medical records are reviewed
Colorado law can still provide benefits if work aggravated a preexisting condition, but lying about it destroys credibility. Failing to keep copies of medical records and claim documents weakens your case. If a mistake was made in what you told a doctor's office, inform your attorney and ask about clarifying the record at the next visit.
Colorado workers compensation law has strict timelines, and missing them is one of the most serious common mistakes. Reporting a workplace injury promptly is critical to comply with state-mandated deadlines.
Under Colorado statute, you must report your injury to your employer in writing within days of when it occurs-not weeks, not months. The formal claim for workers compensation benefits also has a statutory deadline measured in years, and missing it can bar your claim entirely.
Delays in reporting give the employer and insurance carrier an excuse to claim the injury happened at home, over the weekend, or during some other activity. The longer you wait, the harder it becomes to preserve evidence like witness statements, photographs of the accident scene, and security camera footage.
Protect yourself:
Report your injury in writing the day it happens
Keep copies of written notices, emails, and accident reports
Follow up with your HR department or supervisor if you do not receive acknowledgment
If your claim has already been denied or you suspect a deadline is approaching, call Johnston Law Firm immediately at (719) 309-9484 or send us a message online to discuss next steps.
The insurance adjuster's job is to control costs for the insurance company-not to maximize your benefits, not to ensure you get the best medical treatment, and not to act in your best interest. A workers' comp lawyer protects your rights against insurance companies.
Adjusters may sound friendly on the phone. They may express sympathy. But they are taking notes on everything you say about your symptoms, physical activities, plans for a new job, and daily life.
What not to do:
Don't speculate about how the accident happened
Don't guess about prior injuries
Don't talk about side jobs, hobbies, or weekend plans without legal advice
Don't agree to recorded statements without consulting an attorney-giving a recorded statement without preparation can hurt your credibility
Example: An adjuster calls and says, "So, are you feeling better this week? Getting out of the house at all?" You casually mention you drove to the store and carried in groceries. That gets noted. At a hearing, that casual comment is used to argue you can lift, carry, and stand for long periods without difficulty.
Once you hire Johnston Law Firm, most communication from the insurance company goes through your attorney-not directly to you. Have Steve Johnston review any letters or forms from the insurance company before signing by calling (719) 309-9484.
Facebook, Instagram, TikTok, and other social media platforms are favorite tools for insurance companies investigating Colorado workers comp claims. Insurance companies monitor social media for evidence against claims, and anything posted online can be used as evidence in hearings.
Photos or videos of everyday activities-hiking near the Sangre de Cristos, dancing at a wedding in Pueblo West, lifting grandkids in La Junta-can be taken out of context and used to argue that your doctor's restrictions are unnecessary. Posts showing physical activity can jeopardize your workers' comp claim even if the activity was within your restrictions.
Even "private" accounts are not truly private. Screenshots and shared posts can still reach an insurance adjuster or defense lawyer.
Rules to follow:
Avoid posting about the accident, your symptoms, or your medical treatment
Don't boast about doing things "despite your injury"
Don't criticize your employer or medical providers online
Avoid discussing your case on social media to protect your claim
Your best bet is to either stay off social media entirely while the case is open or post only neutral, non-physical content after talking with your attorney. If harmful posts already exist, bring them up honestly with your lawyer so the legal team is not blindsided later.
Temporary disability benefits are meant to replace lost wages. Earning income on the side without disclosure is one of the most dangerous mistakes to avoid. Taking side work while on workers' comp may be considered fraud, and your temporary disability benefits may decrease if you earn income from side work.
Mowing lawns for cash, doing construction side work on weekends, or driving rideshare while still drawing wage-loss benefits can trigger serious consequences. Insurers compare tax returns, bank records, and surveillance footage to look for undisclosed income and may refer suspected fraud for criminal investigation.
A limited, approved return to work within restrictions at your regular employer is different from freelancing on the side-but even legitimate work must be coordinated carefully and reported to the insurance company.
Talk with Johnston Law Firm before accepting any new job or informal gig while receiving workers comp benefits. Steve Johnston also handles personal injury and automobile accidents, so potential third-party claims-like being hit by a negligent driver while working-should be discussed as well.
Quitting your job can jeopardize your workers' comp benefits in ways most people don't anticipate. Quitting your job can lead to losing workers' comp benefits because the insurance company will argue that any later wage loss is your choice, not the result of the injury.
Quitting also makes it harder to argue for ongoing restrictions, accommodations, or vocational rehabilitation because the employment relationship has ended. Quitting your job may complicate future workers' comp claims if your condition worsens.
If the workplace truly is unsafe or hostile, speak to an attorney first. Colorado law prohibits retaliation for filing a workers' comp claim, but proving it takes careful documentation. Options may include reporting hazards, documenting retaliation, or filing a complaint-all of which are stronger strategies than simply walking out.
Consult a lawyer before quitting your job while on workers' comp. Contact Johnston Law Firm before turning in a resignation letter or accepting a "voluntary separation" package during an open claim.
Starting a new job or changing your hours or pay while on workers' comp directly affects how wage-loss benefits are calculated. Failing to disclose a new position can be characterized as misrepresentation, even if you believed the job was temporary or light duty.
Changes that must always be disclosed:
Going from part-time to full-time work
Starting remote desk work
Accepting a lower-paying position within restrictions
Beginning self-employment
Taking a new job within your doctor's restrictions is not automatically wrong, but it must be evaluated carefully so you understand how it changes your benefit rights. Workers who accept significantly lower wages due to their injury may actually strengthen a claim for ongoing disability.
If you are thinking about a new job-especially after a serious back, neck, or shoulder work injury-call (719) 309-9484 or contact Johnston Law Firm online for advice first. Steve Johnston's experience with Social Security Disability law can also be important if the injury may permanently prevent a return to work at any job.
Colorado insurers sometimes hire investigators who follow injured workers, especially in more rural areas where outdoor activity is common. There is no law prohibiting you from going on vacation while on workers' comp, but everything you do must stay within your doctor's orders and restrictions.
Activities that commonly appear in surveillance footage and can reflect poorly on your claim:
Shoveling snow in Pueblo during winter
Hunting in the mountains during elk season
Riding ATVs in Huerfano County
Loading heavy lifting items or luggage into a truck
Playing sports at a community park
Even one short clip of you doing something outside your restrictions can be enough to damage your credibility with a workers' compensation judge. Before planning a big trip, major home project, or strenuous activity, review your restrictions in writing and talk to your attorney if there is any doubt.
Careful compliance protects both your health and your right to continued medical treatment and wage benefits throughout your recovery.
Once you sign a Uniform Settlement Agreement in a Colorado workers' compensation case, you may permanently give up rights to additional medical treatment and wage-loss benefits related to that injury. You cannot go back later and ask for more money simply because your condition worsens unexpectedly.
Insurers often offer a lump sum soon after a disability rating is assigned, especially if the doctor chosen by the insurance company gave a conservative impairment rating. Accepting a quick settlement may discourage future claims for worsening conditions, additional surgeries, injections, or pain management.
Never sign a settlement agreement without a thorough review by a workers compensation attorney who understands how future medical needs can affect the value of your workers comp case. Impairment ratings assigned by insurer-selected doctors sometimes undervalue sensory deficits, chronic pain, and functional limitations.
Contact Johnston Law Firm for a detailed evaluation of any settlement offer-including the disability rating, average weekly wage calculation, and potential future medical needs. Call (719) 309-9484 or send us a message online before accepting any settlement proposal.
Once a Colorado workers' comp claim is denied or benefits are cut off, the process becomes technical and legalistic. Not hiring a lawyer can lead to overlooked important steps that cost you benefits permanently. Hearings before Colorado workers' compensation judges involve rules of evidence, expert medical testimony, and strict procedural timelines.
What an experienced workers comp attorney like Steve Johnston handles:
Obtaining complete medical records and claim documentation
Cross-examining insurance medical experts about their impairment ratings
Preparing you to testify clearly and consistently
Negotiating settlements that account for future medical needs
Filing appeals when a decision is unfavorable
Hiring a lawyer costs you nothing upfront. Johnston Law Firm typically handles workers' comp cases on a contingency-fee basis, meaning attorney fees are generally paid only if the firm recovers benefits or a settlement for you. Legal representation can help you navigate complex workers comp laws, and consulting a lawyer can prevent costly mistakes in your claim. A lawyer can help maximize your workers' compensation benefits.
There is no downside to getting a free consultation early, even if your initial claim has not yet been denied benefits. Call (719) 309-9484 or reach out online if you have any doubts about how your work injury claim is being handled.
Toward the end of medical treatment, your authorized treating physician may declare you at Maximum Medical Improvement (MMI) and assign a permanent impairment or disability rating. This rating directly influences how much compensation you may receive for permanent disability in Colorado.
Insurance-company-selected doctors sometimes give conservative ratings that undervalue the true impact of your injury. This is especially common with serious injuries like spinal fusions, torn rotator cuffs, or traumatic brain injuries from a workplace or automobile accident.
Do not assume the initial rating is fair or final. In some workers compensation cases, independent medical examinations (IMEs) or Division IMEs may be available. Understanding when and how to seek these is a technical legal question that requires experienced counsel.
Talk with Johnston Law Firm about whether to challenge a rating, accept it, or negotiate a settlement based on it. Steve Johnston's broader practice in personal injury and automobile accident cases gives him additional experience evaluating long-term disability and future medical needs-an advantage when the stakes involve your health and financial security for years to come.
Avoiding these five or more core mistakes-and ideally all thirteen-can significantly strengthen your Colorado workers' comp case. Following doctor's advice, being honest and consistent with medical providers, respecting deadlines, and steering clear of side jobs or risky social media posts are central to protecting your workers compensation benefits throughout your recovery.
Don't wait until a crisis-like a notice cutting off benefits, a low settlement offer, or a claim denial-to seek legal advice. Early guidance from an attorney who knows Colorado workers' compensation law can make the difference between receiving what you deserve and walking away with far less.
Johnston Law Firm, LLC in Pueblo helps injured workers across Colorado with workers' comp, personal injury, automobile accidents, Social Security Disability, criminal defense, and estate planning. Whatever legal challenge you face, Steve Johnston and his team are ready to listen.
Call (719) 309-9484 or message the firm online to schedule a free, no-obligation consultation about your workers' compensation claim. Your case online review starts with a single call to our office today.
Colorado law does not automatically forbid vacations while receiving workers comp benefits. However, all activities during the trip must comply with your doctor's orders and restrictions. Heavy lifting, long hikes at high altitude, skiing, or other strenuous tourism can be used against your claim if inconsistent with your documented limitations.
Get written approval from your medical provider and speak with your attorney before taking a major trip, especially if air travel, long drives, or physical excursions are involved. Vacations are a common surveillance target, so injured workers should behave exactly as limited as they report feeling in medical appointments.
Whether you can safely drive depends on your specific injury, medications, and your doctor's written restrictions-not simply on the fact that you are on workers' comp. If your injury affects your ability to brake, steer, or turn your head, or if medications cause drowsiness, your doctor may restrict or forbid driving.
Ask your medical provider directly, get any limitations in writing, and follow them carefully. Being seen driving long distances or commercial vehicles while supposedly unable to work can raise red flags with an insurance adjuster.
You can sometimes start a new job while receiving benefits, but doing so will likely affect the type and amount of benefits you receive. Any new job must comply with your doctor's restrictions and must be disclosed to the insurance company to avoid accusations of misrepresentation. In some cases, vocational changes may support a claim for ongoing disability if you must accept significantly lower wages due to the injury. Talk with a workers compensation attorney before accepting a new position.
Colorado law gives employers and insurers significant control over the initial choice of authorized treating physician, but injured workers may have options to request a one-time change or seek a second opinion under § 8-43-404. Do not simply stop going to the approved doctor and switch on your own without understanding the potential effect on payment of medical bills. Document your concerns-rushed visits, ignored complaints, unsafe return-to-work approvals-and discuss them with a workers compensation attorney. Contact Johnston Law Firm to review whether a change of provider, an IME, or another strategy is appropriate for your specific case.
Colorado's workers' compensation system is generally no-fault, meaning you can usually receive benefits even if you made a mistake that contributed to the injury. Benefits may be reduced or denied benefits in limited situations involving intentional self-harm, willful safety violations, or intoxication-but these are fact-specific legal issues. Do not assume you are disqualified just because you fear you did something wrong. Reach out to Johnston Law Firm for a confidential review of your eligibility and protect the benefits you deserve.